Sick's Stadium

Sick's Stadium
Site of Professional Baseball in Seattle for 38 Years. Home to the Rainiers, Steelheads, and Pilots Among Others.

Friday, November 25, 2011

CBA Part 1: Regulation of Smokeless Tobacco

Major League Baseball’s new five-year collective bargaining agreement contains a number of new provisions. I would like to spend part of the offseason discussing some of the various aspects of the new CBA.

The CBA makes some important changes to divisional alignment, playoff structure, and the first-year amateur player draft. One relatively minor provision in the new CBA places some limitations on players’ use of smokeless tobacco, without actually banning its use.

Specifically, under the CBA, players have agreed to no longer carry in their pockets, at times when fans are in the ballpark, tobacco cans or packages. Players will also no longer be able to use tobacco during pregame or postgame interviews or at team functions.

Of course, these restrictions do not actually limit the use of tobacco on the field. Players just will not be able to carry the tins in their back pockets.

It is unclear why these new regulations were instituted; though, obviously the players’ union made these minor concessions at the urging of the Commissioner and politicians—who pushed a far more stringent ban on all on-field tobacco use. The new regulations do nothing to promote healthier ballplayers, as players will still be permitted to dip as much as they want. The regulations do not shield impressionable children from seeing their idols dip, as players will still fill their lower lip with dip as televisions cameras zoom in and broadcast their bulging lips and cheeks on oversized high-definition televisions for children everywhere to see and emulate.

Minor league baseball, where the players are not unionized, banned tobacco use since 1993.

Sunday, November 13, 2011

Which Division is the Strongest in Baseball?

In 1994 Major League Baseball implemented its current playoff configuration: one that includes three divisions and a wild card in each league. Because of the 1994-95 players’ strike, MLB did not utilize its new playoff alignment until the 1995 postseason. The current playoff system has been in place for seventeen seasons.

I wanted to identify the individual divisions that have had the greatest playoff success, so as to find the “strongest division” in baseball. So, the way I measured the strength of these divisions was by adding up how many playoff series each division has won in this modern playoff system.

Here is what I did. I went through the past seventeen postseasons, and I counted how many playoff series each division won each postseason. This year, for example, the AL West won two series (the Rangers won the ALDS and ALCS); the AL Central won one series (Tigers won an ALDS); the AL East, NL East, and NL West each won zero series (the Rays, Yankees, Phillies, and Diamondbacks were all bumped without winning a series); and, the NL Central won four series (the Cardinals won three series—an NLDS, NLCS, and WS; and, the Brewers won one, a NLDS).

The totals reveal the most powerful postseason division the past seventeen seasons: the AL East. The NL East finished a close second place.

AL West: 17
AL Central: 13
AL East: 30

NL West: 15
NL Central: 18
NL East: 26


Most fans are probably not surprised by these numbers. While the AL and NL East have collectively achieved the most post season success, other MLB divisions have been relatively even.

A baseball observer may determine the relative strength of MLB’s various divisions a number of ways: total wins, post season berths, world championships, etc. But, I have not seen this particular measurement, which builds an obvious advantage into the division that lands the wild card (a wild card winner has won the World Series five times).